Friday, February 28, 2014

The Bait and Switch

The Bait and Switch

In the Canada I imagine, every schoolchild can define lies, misrepresentation, fraud, bait and switch, extortion, can recognize these crimes when encountered, can protect him/herself against them, will make restitution when wrongs are revealed, and will stand up to ensure that no others are victimized. Canadians will recognize that what the government did to First Nations people with the Indian Act of 1876 was a crime, a result of the misrepresentation of treaty negotiators, of a government which had not negotiated in good faith, which then committed a bait and switch. First Nations had been baited, convinced to agree to share their traditional territories, to settle on land reserved for them, to accept government assistance to establish themselves in a lifestyle to replace the one lost by environmental degradation (the decimation of the buffalo caused by immigration to the south.) But once they were on reserve, the deal was switched. Now they were no longer considered a sovereign nation capable of managing their own lives as they had done for generations. Now they were child-like, chattels, with every significant decision about their lives controlled by someone from another nation according to policies developed elsewhere, in far-away Ottawa. The bait and switch is the crime to which the rest of us in Canada are all accomplices. A crime from which the rest of us continue to benefit, while First Nations children walk, youth rally, chiefs hold hunger strikes, and people concerned about respect for the environment organize protests.

When governments and corporations say "We have done our fiduciary duty. We consulted" and First Nations say "Nothing we said made any difference to the decision," schoolchildren of the future will recognize another bait and switch. That consultation (the bait) does not mean that "negotiators" across the table have to listen. That hearing words is not the same as accepting input. That closed ears, the switch, are another fraud, another crime, another form of racism. [See Racism below.]


No comments:

Post a Comment