Friday, February 28, 2014

Simple Fear [Ethnocentrism]

Simple Fear [Ethnocentrism]

Once I was travelling by air on the same flight as a man called Ben on a plane heading to a northern Manitoba reserve. Ben was sweating and shaking. I suppose I could have read his symptoms as jonesing, or hangover, or maybe he just had a real phobia about flying. But what I saw was ordinary fear, perhaps because he shared with me that he had never been on an Indian reserve before. Ben was a French-speaking Metis man from somewhere in southern Manitoba or Saskatchewan. He looked First Nations, by which I mean he had black hair and dark brown eyes, and a strong, dare I say, handsome profile. But he had never been on a reserve in his life. And here he was flying north, to an Indian reserve. He had no idea what he might encounter. He was afraid of the unknown. He was afraid of Indians. He knew that he could pass, that he looked native, so what if he approached someone on the reserve, and they spoke to him in Cree, and his only other language is French? Then what? He feared rejection, anger, confrontation. He looked as if he feared for his life.

In the Canada I know, it seems fair to say that most Canadians have never visited a reserve. That Canadians are no different from most people in the world. We tend to be comfortable with what we know and to fear what we do not know. What we do not know we label "other" and marginalize them by not seeing them, by seeming not to care about their issues, by allowing governments to continue to fail them. We also all tend to assume that our own ways work, that we do what we do because it is the best alternative. We tend not to explore, not to care about differences, especially among groups with whom we have little actual contact.

In the Canada I imagine, every schoolchild can explain the meaning of "ethnocentrism" and "cultural relativism" and can explain how such terms impact upon her/him personally. How we all grow up within our own small circle of family and community, acculturated to the beliefs of our group, and often prepped to reject those of others, to assume that our values are "right" and that alternatives are "wrong" or "evil" or "medieval" or "savage." And to fear what we do not know or understand. In the Canada I envision, every child will read Wade Davis and apply his wisdom to Canada. "There are other options, other possibilities, other ways of thinking and interacting with the earth." [Wayfinders, p.2] Anthropology teaches of the necessity to "step back from the constraints of one's own prejudices and pre-conceptions . . . to learn the way [others] perceive the world," [W., p.68] to make "informed judgments." [W., p.69]


No comments:

Post a Comment