Friday, February 28, 2014

Imagine

Imagine

In anticipation of the year 2017 when Canada will mark our sesquicentennial, Canadians who love this land are being asked to envision our ideal nation, to imagine the country we hope to become.

Our Home On Native Land

Our Home On Native Land

Years ago, in a small town in British Columbia, I heard Ovide Mercredi, the then chief of the Assembly of First Nations, in an after-lunch speech, suggest to us that every time we sing O Canada we should be singing "our home on native land." 

At the time, I thought he was joking.

Honour . . .

Honour . . .

In the Canada I imagine, every opening ceremony, every welcome speech, every service begins with: "We stand here today through the generosity of the ____ First Nation who (in Treaty # _ ) agree to share their ancestral homeland with us in return for some very basic promises. . . . We thank them. We honour them."

Invisibility

Invisibility

One summer my friend Claire was early. She was waiting alone in a classroom for the professor and the other students to arrive. Two young women came to the door, looked in, and proclaimed: "There's no one here." Claire fumed. No one here! Am I no one? But she didn't confront them, assuming, based on their insensitive remark, that they were too self-centred to care. To see her, to acknowledge her presence, to be concerned about her feelings. It seems to me that we here in Canada have done the same thing to our First Nations. We arrived in this vast land, wrapped up in ourselves, and didn't even see them, regardless of what the law said, or even the law of good manners, we did not even acknowledge their presence. To us, they were nothing, in the same way as, to the early Canadian politicians, their small numbers in a seemingly endless "wilderness" were merely an official impediment to development which had to be addressed quickly before expansion, railroad building, immigration, resource extraction could begin. And dismiss them we did. As if they did not matter. As if we did not care.

In my Dancing With Ghosts: A Cross-Cultural Education I talk about how most of us in Canada grow up in a de facto apartheid world, ignorant of our history and of the history of our relationship with our aboriginal landmates. http://www.dancingwithghostsaneducation.blogspot.ca/


Aboriginal Rights and Title

Aboriginal Rights and Title

In the Canada I imagine, Canadians see and acknowledge the First Nations into whose homeland we have moved. Canadians will know that at the time of contact, British law required that agreements be finalized with First Nations before settlement was permitted in their ancestral territory. Canadians will know that this acknowledgement constitutes an official recognition of nation status, and of aboriginal title based on the right of prior occupancy (not derived from British law but accepted in it.) And that nation status, aboriginal title, any human right cannot be bought, signed away, sold, voluntarily surrendered, relinquished, or extorted, under the threat of war, extermination, or starvation. They were nations before we got here and they are still nations. They had existing rights and these rights still exist.

We (Canadians) Just Don't Understand

We (Canadians) Just Don't Understand

In the Canada I imagine, Canadians are proud of our original peoples and wish to see their circumstances improved, their issues addressed. With the possible exception of frustrated bigots who post Comments, and of some columnists who seem to be paid to be ignorant and abusive, I like to believe that most of us in Canada are compassionate and empathetic. We care about what happens to others, even though we tend to be fairly ignorant ourselves, uneducated, about what the real issues are, about the history, about the people, about the law, especially international law.

First Nations do have some privileges, the laid-back but caring Canadian laments. Something about taxes, something about education, something about reserve lands. But there always seem to be a lot of complaints.

Complaints about what?

Who knows? Neil Young says, about environmental degradation. And something about Treaties? About honour? And young urban people, Idle No More, seem to want something. And rural kids are walking somewhere. And chiefs are going on hunger strikes. And fighting amongst themselves about which head of the monster to attack first. And wherever there are proposals for fracking or for oil tankers or pipelines, or land being expropriated, or sacred territory being desecrated, or when the government tries to interfere in local affairs, or refuses to address crucial issues, some of them seem to protest.

I can't keep up, this poorly-served citizen complains. Poorly served by his or her leaders and by the equally ignorant media. "Who ever wins, fighting the government?" he or she shrugs. It's not really my business. It's not up to me. Quite frankly, I don't understand it.

In the Canada I imagine, the majority of Canadians, beginning with the children, will be educated in our shameful history of failure to honour our First Nations, will choose to seek out hidden truths previously kept from them, and will insist upon action to right historic and current wrongs.


The Fiduciary Responsibility

The Fiduciary Responsibility

In the Canada I imagine, every schoolchild will be able to explain why First Nations always seem to be fighting the government. (Explain the fiduciary responsibility of the federal government towards First Nations people as outlined in the Constitution Act of 1982, formerly the British North America Act of 1867.) Why does the federal government always seem to be in such opposition to First Nations concerns? Who defines what constitutes a First Nation, a nation, a tribe, a tribal council, a band, a band council? Who says First Nations must adopt a European-devised system of democracy with elections, allowing numbers to determine what will be and what will not? How is it possible to have a fiduciary responsibility to an equal?

What if the First Nations have a fiduciary responsibility to the rest of us, as they did in the beginning when they taught us how to survive on this land?

In the Canada I imagine, every Canadian schoolchild will be able to explain what is meant by self-determination and self-government, the significance of national identity, of being recognized, acknowledged as sovereign nations with their own ways of doing things, running their own lives. Nations within a nation. [See below: Define colonialism and apply it to the situation of Canadian First Nations.] Every Canadian schoolchild will be familiar with the United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous People, and with how these rights apply in Canada.


Honouring the Treaties

Honouring the Treaties

In the Canada I imagine, every Canadian schoolchild will understand what "honouring the treaties" means. He or she will be able to explain the significance of sovereign nations agreeing to sign treaty with the newcomers, the new confederation, as equals, to conclude mutually acceptable agreements, with each signatory gaining something and each signatory agreeing to certain commitments.

Treaty-making. Equality, nation to nation. The Indians received/agreed to a promise of mutual occupation. They would continue to live here and they would allow the newcomers to live here. There were no forced migrations which happened in so many colonized territories. They received land reserved for Indians and were guaranteed permission, in order to continue to live as they chose, to access the resources of traditional territory into which newcomers would be moving. [A share of the wealth and a say in what happens to the land and its resources.]

In return for moving over, sharing the land, the Indians were promised something of equal or greater value in return. Food. Clothing. Shelter. Education. Medicine. And specifics of concern to each band or tribe. The Canadian government received: the consent of the First Nations to abandon their seasonally-determined lifestyle following the natural cycles of food and climate and to move on to land reserved for them without giving up their rights to hunt, fish, or forage on traditional territory. Without giving up their share of or control over the resources contained within that territory. Without giving up their title, entitlement, to the land itself. (Remember "Our home on native land?) The Indians agreed to live in peace, to not make war with other tribes or with new settlers. They trusted the government signatories to manage future settlement and development, assuming that this did not or would not interfere with their existing rights, and in return for the promised assistance to reestablish themselves in a lifestyle equal to or better than the one they knew before. 

Share the land. Honour the treaties. Nation to nation.

The Spirit of Treaty-Making

The Spirit of Treaty-Making

In the Canada I imagine, every schoolchild will be able to explain the meaning of The Spirit of Treaty-making and how the Spirit of Treaty-making applies to them. Even retroactively, to traditional territories lost before Confederation, before post-Confederation treaty-making began (where the First Nations still had aboriginal title.) And how the spirit of treaty-making applies to those immense tracts already overrun (BC) where treaties have yet to be signed.

A treaty is a nation-to-nation agreement, an agreement between equals, concerning mutual occupation of shared territory. In the Canada I imagine, every child will understand how unilateral action coming "down" from Ottawa is a breach of nation-to-nation protocol and a dishonour to treaties and treaty-making.


Colonialism

Colonialism

In the Canada I imagine, every Canadian schoolchild will be able to explain the meaning of colony, and colonialism, and how the new Canadian government in 1867 determined to make colonies out of the nations who had aboriginal title. How they dishonoured the spirit of treaty-making. How they passed a law, the Indian Act of 1876, without consultation or First Nations input, effectively making formerly sovereign nations wards of the Crown, subjects.

The Indian Act in effect instituted a form of apartheid in Canada, confining Indians to reserves, with every aspect of their lives controlled from elsewhere and the domination enforced by politically-appointed agents stationed on reserves. The Indian Act instituted assimilation as official government policy to be carried out by enforcement of laws outlawing cultural activities and removing children from families and communities, placing them in residential schools to colonize them by educating them in the ways of the mainstream. 

The Bait and Switch

The Bait and Switch

In the Canada I imagine, every schoolchild can define lies, misrepresentation, fraud, bait and switch, extortion, can recognize these crimes when encountered, can protect him/herself against them, will make restitution when wrongs are revealed, and will stand up to ensure that no others are victimized. Canadians will recognize that what the government did to First Nations people with the Indian Act of 1876 was a crime, a result of the misrepresentation of treaty negotiators, of a government which had not negotiated in good faith, which then committed a bait and switch. First Nations had been baited, convinced to agree to share their traditional territories, to settle on land reserved for them, to accept government assistance to establish themselves in a lifestyle to replace the one lost by environmental degradation (the decimation of the buffalo caused by immigration to the south.) But once they were on reserve, the deal was switched. Now they were no longer considered a sovereign nation capable of managing their own lives as they had done for generations. Now they were child-like, chattels, with every significant decision about their lives controlled by someone from another nation according to policies developed elsewhere, in far-away Ottawa. The bait and switch is the crime to which the rest of us in Canada are all accomplices. A crime from which the rest of us continue to benefit, while First Nations children walk, youth rally, chiefs hold hunger strikes, and people concerned about respect for the environment organize protests.

When governments and corporations say "We have done our fiduciary duty. We consulted" and First Nations say "Nothing we said made any difference to the decision," schoolchildren of the future will recognize another bait and switch. That consultation (the bait) does not mean that "negotiators" across the table have to listen. That hearing words is not the same as accepting input. That closed ears, the switch, are another fraud, another crime, another form of racism. [See Racism below.]


Environmental Degradation

Environmental Degradation

Once I heard a First Nations elder proclaim: "My grandfather always told me not to piss in the river." When the elder said this at a public meeting, there were lowered eyes, hands over mouths, titters, and shuffling feet. We don't talk about bodily functions that freely in mixed company so we listeners missed his point. Traditional teaching forbids polluting the waters, this elder was telling us. Traditional teaching recommends land-based waste disposal, trains young people to respect nature, expects behaviour to demonstrate proper regard for the environment and towards other people sharing the land, living downstream. How can we learn to recognize those underlying traditional values? Arguments, or First Nations curricula which focus on how to make bannock and how to trap a fur-bearing animal and how to tan a hide, often risk missing important points. Although all three are examples of adaptation, of how First Nations welcomed contact with European traders who brought wheat flour with them and wanted prime pelts and were willing to barter, these are outward and visible signs of a disappearing lifestyle. Culture includes more than lifestyle. Traditional attitudes, knowledge about the waters, the earth, the animals, the spirit realm, lie somewhat deeper than skins and camp cooking. And it is the ancient underlying wisdom of those relationships, even for people who may never have been trappers, which must inform the teachings upon which consultations and negotiations are based. These teachings which will be passed to future generations, which may indeed save the rest of us, intruders with too little concern, from the consequences of our own lack of respect. Of our willingness to put money, wealth, economic development before respect for the environment. How does that slogan go? "If you don't respect the land, it will die, and it will take you with it."

Unfortunately, most of us today live in urban settings, where concrete and pavement prevent our feet from touching Mother Earth. Where many children never see their food while it is still alive. As children we were taught about the extermination of the passenger pigeon, the great auk, the American bison, Atlantic cod, and the threatened wild Pacific salmon. Extermination caused by people who did not care, did not respect the life spark in other living creatures. Who killed for fun or for money. In the Canada I imagine, all children will recognize that our life comes from the the earth which feeds us, and that, for as simple a reason as self-preservation, we must care for the planet in a way that allows the earth to continue to sustain us.


In the Canada I imagine, First Nations exercise their right to insist that others who benefit financially are not allowed to destroy that which nourishes the people and their cultures. They exercise their right to share, to manage the land and resources, to control who is allowed in and what they are allowed to do. If these life-sustaining relationships are ignored, impoverished reserves will continue to become the garbage dumps of the cities, paid to accept the excess which municipal and provincial regulations outlaw. And the Canada of the future will be defined by words from the past. "They paved paradise and put up a parking lot." And our children, like those in Beijing, will have to be taught the meaning of the expression: "sky blue."

Simple Fear [Ethnocentrism]

Simple Fear [Ethnocentrism]

Once I was travelling by air on the same flight as a man called Ben on a plane heading to a northern Manitoba reserve. Ben was sweating and shaking. I suppose I could have read his symptoms as jonesing, or hangover, or maybe he just had a real phobia about flying. But what I saw was ordinary fear, perhaps because he shared with me that he had never been on an Indian reserve before. Ben was a French-speaking Metis man from somewhere in southern Manitoba or Saskatchewan. He looked First Nations, by which I mean he had black hair and dark brown eyes, and a strong, dare I say, handsome profile. But he had never been on a reserve in his life. And here he was flying north, to an Indian reserve. He had no idea what he might encounter. He was afraid of the unknown. He was afraid of Indians. He knew that he could pass, that he looked native, so what if he approached someone on the reserve, and they spoke to him in Cree, and his only other language is French? Then what? He feared rejection, anger, confrontation. He looked as if he feared for his life.

In the Canada I know, it seems fair to say that most Canadians have never visited a reserve. That Canadians are no different from most people in the world. We tend to be comfortable with what we know and to fear what we do not know. What we do not know we label "other" and marginalize them by not seeing them, by seeming not to care about their issues, by allowing governments to continue to fail them. We also all tend to assume that our own ways work, that we do what we do because it is the best alternative. We tend not to explore, not to care about differences, especially among groups with whom we have little actual contact.

In the Canada I imagine, every schoolchild can explain the meaning of "ethnocentrism" and "cultural relativism" and can explain how such terms impact upon her/him personally. How we all grow up within our own small circle of family and community, acculturated to the beliefs of our group, and often prepped to reject those of others, to assume that our values are "right" and that alternatives are "wrong" or "evil" or "medieval" or "savage." And to fear what we do not know or understand. In the Canada I envision, every child will read Wade Davis and apply his wisdom to Canada. "There are other options, other possibilities, other ways of thinking and interacting with the earth." [Wayfinders, p.2] Anthropology teaches of the necessity to "step back from the constraints of one's own prejudices and pre-conceptions . . . to learn the way [others] perceive the world," [W., p.68] to make "informed judgments." [W., p.69]


Racism

Racism

In the Canada I imagine, every schoolchild can define racism, and can recognize racism when they encounter it in person or in policies or legislation. That racism is the belief that one race is superior and that that superiority gives them the right to dominate, to control how others live. Every child will recognize that the failure of the federal government to negotiate in good faith was a result of racism, of feeling superior to the First Nations. That the decision to pass the Indian Act was based upon the racist belief that white Canadians were superior and whatever they decided would be an improvement for First Nations people. That the imposition of residential schools was a policy based on the racist belief that First Nations children would be better off away from the influence of their families and communities so that they could be immersed into the language, values, and traditions of the superior white culture. That the continued dishonouring of treaties and of the spirit of treaty-making is based on a racist failure to accept First Nations as separate and equal.

 In the Canada that I envision, every child will recognize "the truth about reconciliation," that no reconciliation between First Nations and Canadians is possible while the government and the people of Canada are still informed by the racist belief that mainstream culture is superior, that Euro-centric values are superior, and that Canada will be improved when Indians have been assimilated, when the people to whom we owe such a debt have ultimately been "disappeared."


Assimilation

Assimilation

In the Canada I imagine, every child will understand the meaning of assimilation--the belief that First Nations will be better off as soon as they become like us--and how the idea of assimilation is a racist tenet, based upon the racist belief that European-centred culture and values are superior. That oft-heard admonitions such as "Speak White!" are shortcut versions of a command to assimilate. That the assertion that "when First Nations accept 'economic development' all their problems will be solved," the hidden agenda is assimilation (accept our values) and assimilation is a form or racism. 

Trust. Respect. Honour.

Trust. Respect. Honour.

In the Canada that I imagine, Canadians will be guided by words of elder wisdom: "We are here to help each other through."


In the Canada I imagine, every opening ceremony, every welcome speech, every service begins: "We rise here today through the generosity of the ____ First Nation who (in Treaty # _) agree to share this, their ancestral homeland, with us in return for some very basic commitments. Gratefully, we respect their willingness to accept us, their promise to show us how to live in peace. We honour them as we honour the treaties which brought us here to Our Home On Native Land."

Canada in the World

Canada in the World

In the Canada I imagine, the world will see us as a peace-loving nation where we honour and respect each other in word and in deed.


Imagine.      

Monday, February 24, 2014